JK Rowling, Cancel Culture, and the Gradual Demise of the West

Real life dementors are swooping around JK Rowling and they’re coming for you too.

JK Rowling has found herself caught up in cancel culture. Both JK Rowling and Harry Potter are currently trending on Twitter. There are 100,000s comments and memes expressing outrage. Indeed many of these tweets are themselves outrageous and even abusive. 

What did JK Rowling say to invoke such anger? She dared challenge the culture’s narrative.

“If sex isn’t real, there’s no same-sex attraction. If sex isn’t real, the lived reality of women globally is erased. I know and love trans people, but erasing the concept of sex removes the ability of many to meaningfully discuss their lives. It isn’t hate to speak the truth.”

Let’s be clear, JK Rowling hasn’t said anything controversial. She has simply noted an established fact: a scientific, biological, and sociological fact. Indeed, sex is one of the few self evident truths that has been universally accepted in all human history and across cultures, that is, until the last few years. In today’s Western world, to affirm that women are women and that men are men is to speak heresy. To suggest sex is real is paramount to signing your own incarceration to Azkaban.

lbj101-1113_2018_185535

Our societies have been occupied by other important issues of late, especially the COVID-19 pandemic and now racism. The response to JK Rowling is a reminder however that even a pandemic and racism don’t diminish the fervour of those following the latest chapter in the sexual revolution. Again note, we are talking about half a million comments stemming from a simple statement affirming that women are women. This shows us how nothing is to excuse, distract, or dilute, full and unquestioned adherence to the sexual milieu.

While our attention has been necessarily elsewhere, the Victorian Government is still planning to introduce legislation this year that may well prohibit classical Christian teaching on sex and gender. Also, over the past few days, The Australian has published two important articles exposing the wrongful conflation of autism with gender dysphoria. Girls with autism are being misdiagnosed with gender dysphoria and are undergoing treatment to change their gender.

“Professor Attwood, a psychologist based in Brisbane and author of the guide known globally as the “Asperger’s bible”, said unhurried and thoughtful gender change could be a success but he worried about a crash back into depression if trans status was embraced with impulsive and unrealistic hopes of a fix for autism“Once they’ve changed gender, they still have autism and when (gender) transition doesn’t solve their problems they think, Oh no, that was the only option I had, what’s the point of life?,” he told The Australian.

“One of the characteristics of autism is what we call a one-track mind, and sometimes the issue of gender dysphoria (discomfort with one’s body) and changing gender becomes a special interest with a phenomenal knowledge and determination.”

Not even medicine is immune to popular social theory. Our culture’s inability to affirm basic scientific and social truth exposes a growing distrust of authority and a preference to determine moral goodness by personal inclinations. This has the negative effect of harming children and creating greater social disharmony.

As today’s example with JK Rowling demonstrates, hardline secularists preach a message of tolerance that is soaked in hateful speech. They call for justice and acceptance while demeaning everyone around them and demanding their silence. Secularist sermons are as religious as the most ardent fundamentalist. They are as confident as the Titanic sailing from the shores of England and will prove to be as successful.  Except, in this case, the new moral arbiters are not waiting for the iceberg to hit, they are already busy throwing overboard anyone and everyone who questions the decided course, which is to hit the iceberg. That is the agenda. We are not witnessing the rebirth of Western culture as much as we are signalling its gradual demolition.

The project of relativising truth was all along about breaking down society in order to introduce a new and authoritarian truth. This new order exists without reason and grace and it insists on our total allegiance. Gender theory serves as the flagship for the new orthodoxy. The fact that this theory keeps bending and changing every few months is ignored by the most vocal evangelists. Whatever its latest iteration, unwavering conformity is demanded.

Paul Kelly has offered this insightful analysis of the fracturing of Western culture. He says,

“The progressive mantra is that Western liberalism is immoral with its tolerance of colonialism, invasion, racism, inequality, climate cowardice, sexism and patriarchy. While Australians are pragmatic and responsive to sensible changes in the liberal status quo, progressivism demands a new moral order that unnerves and divides the community. It is about power. It sees every issue in terms of a victim class and an oppressor class. It is more interested in power than solutions. It demands people change their values to fit its moral impositions and it is disgusted by how liberalism has tolerated so many reactionary views…”

“…American writer Yuval Levin argued in his 2016 book, The Fractured Republic, that culture was being re-engineered. It was now what the individual preferred it to be. Once your guiding star becomes your own self-expression then, as Levin says, we “recoil from any demands that we conform to the requirements of some external moral standard — a set of rules that keeps ‘me’ from being ‘the real me’, ‘true to myself’ ”.

Such rules were to be discarded. Indeed, they were to be mocked, with the Christian religion top of the list. Such individual empowerment leads to defiance of moral instructions handed down by church, state or nearly any authority. Those defying the authority are applauded because being “true to yourself” is seen as the ultimate morality.”

Jesus declares that the “truth sets us free”. Yet, we see our society abandoning truth on many fronts; not only Christian truths but also universal knowledge. We see it with our attitudes toward the unborn, we see it when society denigrates other races, and it’s evident in our whitewashing of sex and gender. The situation is made more complex because past generations have not always offered a better discourse. Examples abound of where Western culture has previously suppressed self evident moral truth in the name of other ideologies, but this is no justification for repeating the sin of Adam today.

As Paul Kelly suggests in his article, Western societies like Australia are likely to become more fragmented and tribal. One of the byproducts of this is that as we grow weaker, we become more vulnerable. The sun is slowly setting on the West, less because of emerging powers like Communist China, but because like Rome we have chosen to destroy ourselves. At times we highlight genuine issues and then weaponise them to knock each other out. Agreement is often aloof and kindness even more distant. It is telling that as a society we can no longer agree on what a woman is and what a man is.

That there are individuals who believe they are born in the wrong body cannot be denied. That most children who wrestle with this disjuncture find the issue resolved as they grow into adulthood is also a fact. That some individuals continue to struggle with their gender identity does not mean we dismiss biological facts, but it does require us to find suitable ways to love and support them. Indeed, while Christian ethics is largely dismissed by today’s cultural elites, it is the Bible belief that all people are made in the image of God that teaches us that all people matter. We do not leave those aside those who are crying for help, rather we come alongside them.

The West is in trouble. As a Christian, my primary focus is not on keeping the West. However, to say none of it matters is simply naive. With all its flaws and failures, Western civilisation has given the world liberties and life that have not grown elsewhere. Again, the very notion of human equality and dignity depends on Judeo-Christian teaching.  If the West is to be saved, we need to rediscover the very doctrines upon which it was built, and indeed the very same teachings that are now flourishing in many other parts of the world; name Christianity. This exercise, however, requires humility and even repentance. At the moment, there is little appetite for either.

12 thoughts on “JK Rowling, Cancel Culture, and the Gradual Demise of the West

  1. Yes good stuff Murray. You’ve stated it well: “In today’s Western world, to affirm that women are women and that men are men is to speak heresy.”
    Note the political leaders who have swivelled around on the issue of marriage at one point conceding that marriage is a man-woman relationship for life (the bipartisan amendments to the 2004 Marriage Act when both sides went hunting for “conservative” Christian votes) and 13 years later with the posturing of “both sides” over the ambiguous result of a bogus ABS social survey (one closed YES/NO question) resulting in the air-brushing out of the Marriage Act of husband-wife marriage in December 2017. And we are told it is simply because “love is love”. Problem is however, mushy sentimentalism aside, love has thus been redefined as a function of sexuality. The rage at J K Rowling’s comments suggest “sexualité sans frontières”, an ideology that simply does not want to be faced with the male-female human responsibility for procreation. Such responsibility is integral to who we are and how we got here and what the future is going to hold for subsequent generations. But Harry Potter’s author has said something that challenges the dogmatic and abstract functionalist view of love as a merely a mode of sexuality, by appeal to matters which other adult women – mothers and wives – and hopefully men – fathers and husbands – as well, know only too well.
    BTW Parts of this worthy essay might need some slight correction – insertion of words etc.

    Like

  2. The Bible does not actually say love is love. The quote is from 1 John and it says caring-love is caring-love and there is no sexual overtones in the sentence whatsoever.

    Like

    • Yes I agree that AGAPE is certainly no mushy sentiment, and the Bible never countenances deceitful avoidance of coherent argument by resorting to obfuscation even if such phrases are “well-loved” (sic!) or have massive “like” tallies. But does not AGAPE refer to our humanity in its fulness in Christ Jesus, our (male-female) image-bearing, so we can indeed be “fruitful and multiply”?

      Like

  3. Putting aside ‘gender’ for a second; what our generation were taught at school about ‘biological sex’ was greatly simplified compared to the actual science. This has been fixed. Children are now being taught the full story. Google PSHE.
    Watch this & google ‘Intersex’ please. As well as googling ‘the difference between biological sex and gender’

    P.S. Clownfish & some other animals change biological sex all the time. Some animals have no sex.
    —–
    Also maybe check out the last few months of Rowling’s tweets. She is actively destroying trans rights, on purpose.

    Like

    • You mention Science. Can you please clarify what definition of science you’re using? Observational, historical, reconstructional, or other? …and what presuppositional commitments drive that definition? Additionally, do you believe God’s revelation is an objective authority on the subject of love and gender or is is subject to our imagination? Please explain. Thanks

      Like

    • Clownfish & some other animals are irrelevant, since humans are not clownfish or some other animals, and unlike the latter, they cannot change their sex – not even through cross-sex hormones or surgical mutilation.
      What trans rights is Rowling actively destroying? You haven’t told us.

      Like

  4. Pingback: A La Carte (June 8) – Tim Challies | ChriSoNet.Com

  5. Pingback: JK Rowling, Cancel Culture, and the Gradual Demise of the West | MurrayCampbell.net – Reformed faith salsa style

  6. Pingback: All Around the Web – June 10, 2020 – sola evangelii

  7. Pingback: The Lectionary, 13/06/20 – Semper Lectio

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s